Selfie-snapping monkey loses copyright infringement case (again)

Share

The monkey, of course, did not start the fight.

But in 2015, People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals, a US-based animal rights group, filed a suit on Naruto's behalf, claiming the photographer had infringed Naruto's copyright since the monkey had taken the picture himself.

That outcome was no surprise. The Ninth Circuit ruling upholds the decision of a federal judge to dismiss the case in 2016, which PETA appealed.

A United States appeals court sided with photographer David Slater in a years-long legal saga around a grinning photo of a black monkey that became an internet sensation in 2011. As part of the settlement, 25% of future proceeds from "any or all of the monkey selfies" will be donated to charities dedicated to protecting crested macaques in Indonesia. But the court chose to weigh in, anyway.

The judge said Mr Slater is entitled to lawyers' fees and sent the case back to a district court to determine the amount. The judges said PETA was using the animal as an "unwitting pawn" for their agenda.

PETA responded by saying that the monkey "is discriminated against simply because he's a nonhuman animal".

In its ruling, the ninth circuit panel said that PETA had failed to meet the "significant relationship" requirement, and could not sue as Naruto's next friend. Instead, the court surmised PETA must have seen "the proverbial writing on the wall at oral argument", known it was going to lose, then tried to save itself from an unfavorable opinion by ending the appeal.

Nadal Eases Into Barcelona Quarter-Finals
There's no love lost between Rafael Nadal and his uncle Toni despite the two ending their coaching partnership a year ago . The victory saw the Spaniard surpass Romanian Ilie Nastase's record of winning 36 consecutive sets on clay in 1973.

George RR Martin Says 'The Winds of Winter' Won't Publish in 2018
Martin confirmed that the next book in the Song of Ice and Fire series, The Winds of Winter , will not be released this year. Also thrown in the mix will be Aenys, Maegor the Cruel, Jaehaerys I, Viserys I, and Aegon II.

Black Ops 4 Battle Royale replacing Campaign, MW2 Remastered without multiplayer?
One of the possible substitutions for the set-piece heavy campaign is a Battle Royale mode in the vein of PUBG or Fortnite . Activision didn't comment on the rumor to Polygon , but said it will reveal more details about Black Ops 4 on May 17.

Photographer David Slater has won his legal battle over that monkey selfie.

"It remains unclear what claims PETA purported to be 'settling, ' since the court was under the impression this lawsuit was about Naruto's claims".

"PETA apparently obtained something from the settlement with Slater, although not anything that would necessarily go to Naruto", the court wrote, proceeding to describe the agreement.

The 9th Circuit also said refusing to dismiss the case "prevents the parties from manipulating" the precedent set by the judge. "Were he capable of recognizing this abandonment, we wonder whether Naruto might initiate a breach of confidential relationship against his (former) next friend, PETA, for its failure to pursue his interests before its own".

PETA appealed that ruling to the 9th Circuit.

In January 2016 a San Francisco Judge ruled that an animal can not claim copyrights for images.

Share